Better Properties blog

Your Home Is Worth What the Bank Will Lend on It

Five people have an opinion on what your home is worth. Four of them argue. The fifth one decides. Here is what you control.

Every sale has five opinions on what the property is worth. Five. Not one.

You need to know all five. And you need to know which one counts.

But here is the part most sellers miss. You are not powerless in this. You control the inputs the fifth opinion reads. Price, presentation, timing. Those are yours.

1. The seller

You live there. You raised kids there. You renovated the kitchen. You know the neighbours.

So your number is high. Of course it is. It is your home, not a spreadsheet.

That is not a criticism. It is human. But it is still an opinion. And it is the one with the most emotion in it.

Your power here is the choice. You pick the price strategy. You pick the agent. Those two picks shape everything after them.

2. The seller’s agent

That is me, on a listing. My job is to price it to sell, not to flatter you.

A good agent gives you the honest number, even when it costs him the listing. A bad agent gives you the big number, then watches the house sit.

I have written about that one before. The agent who promises the flattering price. Tickle the ear, then the price cuts start.

3. The buyer

The buyer has an opinion too. Usually a lower one.

They have seen five other houses this week. They have a budget. They have a mortgage approval with a hard ceiling. They love your house, but they love it at their number.

Fair. That is their job.

But a buyer is not the whole market. A well-priced home gets more than one buyer through the door. And more than one buyer is what pulls the number up. That is the opportunity in pricing it right. You are not begging one buyer to stretch. You are giving several buyers a reason to compete.

4. The buyer’s agent

The fourth opinion. Also a number, usually close to the buyer’s, but with a job attached.

A good buyer’s agent tells their client when to walk away. A good one also tells them when the house is worth stretching for. Both calls matter. The agent who only ever says stretch is not advising. The agent who only ever says walk is not either.

Four opinions. Four people with something at stake. None of them decides the deal.

5. The bank appraiser

The fifth opinion. The one that matters most.

The appraiser works for the lender, not for you, not for the buyer. He walks the house, he looks at the condition, then he goes back to the sales. Recent sales. Same kind of house. Same area. That is the whole job.

He has never met you. He does not care about your kitchen reno. Sorry.

But that is a map, not a wall. The appraiser reads the sales. Price to the sales he will use, and his number confirms the deal instead of killing it. The appraisal becomes the floor the deal stands on.

What that means in plain English

Say the buyer agrees to pay $1,000,000. The appraiser says the house is worth $950,000.

The bank does not lend on $1,000,000. It lends on $950,000.

So someone has to cover the $50,000 gap. In cash. Or the price gets rewritten. Or the deal falls apart.

That gap is avoidable. Price where the sales support it, and there is no gap to cover. The buyer gets the house. The seller gets the money. The bank signs off. Done right.

If the buyer still has a financing condition, they can walk. If the deal is firm, it is harder. Much harder. So the work happens before the offer, not after it.

That is why an agreed price is not a sold price. Not until the bank signs off.

Cash changes the math

One exception. Cash buyers.

No lender, no appraiser. The buyer pays what they pay, and the deal closes on their money.

But sellers need to understand what cash really buys. A cash buyer who can prove it, proof of funds in hand, is not paying full price out of generosity.

Cash is king in this market. Everyone knows it. A cash offer removes the financing condition. It removes the appraisal. It removes the wait for the bank. It removes the risk that the deal falls apart at the last step.

And the buyer knows that. So they demand a lower price for it. They have removed the risk for the seller, and they charge for that certainty.

That is the trade. And it is a real choice, not a trap. Top dollar with a mortgage behind it, and a small chance the appraisal comes in light. Or a lower cash offer that closes for certain. Both are good answers. Depends on the seller.

Most buyers are not cash buyers. Most buyers need the bank. So for most deals, the fifth opinion is the one that counts. But when a real cash buyer shows up, with proof, do not expect them to pay the same price as everyone else. They are not buying the house. They are buying the certainty. And certainty has a price.

So what do we do about it?

At Better Properties, we put a lot of work into presentation. Staging. Photos. The front door. The light. The smell. The whole first ten seconds.

We want your house to be the best looking property on the street. The one buyers remember on the drive home.

And that work matters. It brings more buyers through the door. More buyers means more offers. More offers means the price the appraiser reads is a real market price. Presentation does not move the appraiser past the sales. It brings the buyers whose offers become the sales.

But presentation has a limit. It moves buyers. It does not move the appraiser past what the sales support.

A beautiful house still has to appraise. A staged living room does not add $50,000 to the comparable sales. The appraiser knows that. The bank knows that.

So we price to the sales. Not to the hope. Not to the reno bill. To the sales the appraiser will actually use.

That is the honest way to price a house. It is also the way that closes.

What this means if you are selling

Price it where the appraiser can defend it. Not where you wish it was.

A house priced to the comps gets offers in the first week, when the listing is fresh and every buyer watching the area gets the alert. That is your best week. Use it.

A house priced to the reno gets showings, then silence, then a price cut. Then another one.

You know that story. Every seller in Toronto knows that story. The fix is not a lower price. The fix is the right price, on day one, when the most buyers are watching.

What this means if you are buying

Do not fall in love with a number the appraiser cannot support. Unless you have the cash to cover the gap.

Love the house. Check the number. Ask your agent what the appraiser will see, before you sign, not after.

That is the question that saves deals. What will the bank say this is worth?

Five opinions. Four of them argue. One of them lends the money. And you set the table for all five.

No rush. But if you are thinking of selling, get the honest number first. Then we will walk it together and price it to close, not just to list.

DM VALUE and I will send you a straight-answer valuation. No fluff. No spam. Just the range, the sales behind it, and what I would do if it were my house.

Watch the video version: Jim Walks the Hood, Ep. 1, Humber Bay Shores, filmed walking the neighbourhood.

Thinking of selling? Get the honest number first, then price it to close, not just to list.

Wondering what a lender would say your home is worth? Start with a straight-answer valuation, and we will walk it together.

Get my home valuation Message Jim on WhatsApp